Is it wrong for Heinz to steal the medicine that saves his wife?

Is it wrong for Heinz to steal the medicine that saves his wife?

Stage one (obedience): Heinz should not steal the medicine because he will consequently be put in prison which will mean he is a bad person. OR Heinz should not steal the medicine because prison is an awful place, and he would more likely languish in a jail cell than over his wife’s death.

Is it actually right or wrong for him to steal the drug Why is it right or wrong?

2. Is it actually right or wrong for him to steal the drug? “It is wrong but he is justified because the druggist appears to be unjustified in his actions.” 2a. He is making a willful decision to damage the druggist’s property and take what does not rightfully belong to him”.

Should Heinz be punished for stealing the medicine?

Heinz should not steal the medicine because the law prohibits stealing, making it illegal. Heinz should steal the drug for his wife but also take the prescribed punishment for the crime as well as paying the druggist what he is owed.

What is the right answer to Heinz dilemma?

Now, to solve this Heinz’s dilemma, the thinker has three options. Heinz should not steal the drug because it is the disobedience of law. Heinz can steal the drug but should be punished by the law. Heinz can steal the drug and no law should punish him.

What is Postconventional morality?

Level 3 – Postconventional morality Postconventional morality is the third stage of moral development, and is characterized by an individuals’ understanding of universal ethical principles. Individual judgment is based on self-chosen principles, and moral reasoning is based on individual rights and justice.

What is Preconventional morality?

A child with pre-conventional morality has not yet adopted or internalized society’s conventions regarding what is right or wrong, but instead focuses largely on external consequences that certain actions may bring.

What if the person dying was a stranger would it make any different?

No, if it was a stranger, it would still not change anything, I would steal the drug. It would be saving a life, which would make me feel good about myself, saving someone else life.

Why is stealing morally wrong?

It is a dilemma because there is a conflict between the choices. Usually one action, though morally right, violates another ethical standard. A classic example is stealing to feed your family. Stealing is legally and ethically wrong, but if your family is starving it might be morally justified.

What is moral dilemma example?

A moral dilemma is a situation in which a person is torn between right and wrong. Some examples of moral dilemmas include: The classic “lifeboat dilemma”, where there are only 10 spaces in the lifeboat, but there are 11 passengers on the sinking ship. A decision must be made as to who will stay behind.

What is an example of Preconventional morality?

Preconventional morality – young children under the age of 9 The first stage highlights the self-interest of children in their decision making as they seek to avoid punishment at all costs. In relation to our example above, the man should not steal the medication from the pharmacy as he may go to jail if he is caught.

What is the Postconventional stage?

At the postconventional level, the individual moves beyond the perspective of his or her own society. Morality is defined in terms of abstract principles and values that apply to all situations and societies. The individual attempts to take the perspective of all individuals.

What is an example of Postconventional morality?

For example, a person who justified a decision on the basis of principled reasoning in one situation (postconventional morality stage 5 or 6) would frequently fall back on conventional reasoning (stage 3 or 4) with another story.

Is it wrong to steal medication to save a life?

Since everyone is stealing medication, frenzy will ensue and there will be no medication left to steal or there will be no more access to medication. Here lies a contradiction, thus deeming this maxim impermissible. This still seems wrong to let our spouse die when we didn’t try everything in our power to help them.

Do you steal medication for your sick spouse?

I will steal medication for my sick spouse since I cannot afford it. Everyone steals medication for their sick spouse since they cannot afford it. Since everyone is stealing medication, frenzy will ensue and there will be no medication left to steal or there will be no more access to medication.

How old are the children in stealing to save a life?

Both children are the same age (11) and grade level (sixth grade), they were given a situation where this doctor created a medication that can save this man’s (Heinz) wife. However, the doctor overpriced the drug at $2000 (10x) what he spent to create the drug.

Why did a man steal to save his wife?

The boy’s response was approval on the man’s action, stealing the drug to save his dying wife. He reasoned that if the man did not steal than his wife would die and even if he did steal which means breaking the law, the judge would not punish him as harshly. In short, the boy’s view was a conflict between property and life.